Shimeji Cultivation Basics
Shimeji cultivation techniques
Introduction
Shimeji, also called bunashimeji, scientific name Hypsizygus marmoreus is a unique, peculiar and very commercially interesting mushroom species. First cultivated by the shochu brewer and food processing giant Takara Shuzou in the early 1970s, shimeji, as I said when I first covered them, were for the first fifteen or so years of their life a limited specialty item, being exclusively contracted to agricultural co-ops in Nagano Prefecture. Since the late 1980s the species has exploded in popularity and it is now on the cusp of overtaking enoki as the most cultivated and consumed mushroom in Japan.
One interesting impact of the rise of shimeji is that they swiftly destroyed Japan’s domestic oyster mushroom industry. To the point where oyster mushrooms here, nationally, constitute just a few thousand tons of production (less than 1% of total mushroom production), and most of that consists of a single legacy product from Hokto and golden oyster mushrooms in Hokkaido, where they are a traditional delicacy. In contrast with most of the western world, where oyster mushrooms are both very popular and widely consumed, its difficult to find them anywhere in Japan, which is, after China, the second biggest mushroom producing country. Why is this?
It is all the fault of shimeji. Namely, how shimeji defeated oyster mushrooms in most metrics. Oyster mushrooms were a pain to sell given how conscious Japanese consumers are of freshness, (leading to supermarkets to constantly be throwing away oyster mushrooms they couldn’t sell fast enough), which combined with their fragility, led to immense logistical challenges. In comparison, shimeji are simple. Shimeji have a 10~14-day shelf life, easily, and they form durable fruiting bodies that don’t fragment and handle well. If that wasn’t enough, shimeji also have considerably higher bioefficiency per bottle than oysters do, producing about 220 grams on an 850 ml bottle compared to only around 130 grams per bottle for a common black oyster mushroom variety.
The only drawback anywhere with shimeji is their relatively long incubation that runs from 80~100 days, though there are some strains and some growers now that have experimented with shorter incubations down to around 70 days. The shorter incubation can impact fruiting consistency and lead to reduced yields, but there is still some hope that in the future a shorter cycle might become commercially feasible given the right spawn, substrate, and cultivation parameters (more on these later). Shimeji though, because of their soft stems, which have a much more pleasant texture than the tough, chewy stems of oyster mushrooms (which become particularly tough when oyster mushrooms are grown with bottle cultivation systems), and because they retain their bulk better, have become the go-to mushrooms in Japan for stewed dishes.
I’ve broached this topic as well in the shimeji issue of the journal, published in 2023, but shimeji have a pleasant, neutral smell, and when cooked, lack any bitterness and have a relatively mild flavor with a faint nuttiness. They also do well to amplify the umami flavors and work well with most other ingredients. This has made shimeji popular in Japan, since they are easy to cook with, and many people now buy the pre-cut shimeji, which have the bottom of the cluster removed making them a bag of loose mushrooms. This has also contributed to the popularity of shimeji as a quick, easy to use mushroom. The texture as well is lighter, less chewy, and without any peculiar crunchiness or crispness, which makes them easier to feed to kids and other people who are picky about food textures.
Substrate
The substrate mixing for shimeji is quite complicated. One element of bottle cultivation systems, is that substrate is even more carefully managed than with bag cultivation systems and the demands higher and the margins of error lower. For shimeji, the standard base is a mixture of beech and cedar sawdust, but without proper supplementation the results will be poor. Six of the most common nutrition supplements, which are used to add nitrogen and certain minerals, or otherwise adjust the physical properties of the substrate, are: ground corn cob, rice bran, wheat bran, soybean hulls, cottonseed hulls, and dried tofu lees (soybean pulp, called okara, which I have also mentioned before in this journal). Lastly, calcium-based pH regulators like lime are also used, but these should average to under 2.5g per 850ml bottle.